collaboration cafe - New York
7.00pm april 13- NY PeterB
-would you be able to get 2 or 3 people from your mining of obama's citizen e-spaces to this in new york-rather than
a general attempt to get a quorum , could we work back from the sort of idea (on right) which
we could ask for help on during june 29 dilaogue with Nobel laureate Muhammad Yunus & friends- therefore for this cafe we dont want people who are bringing conflicting ideas until we have let this baby breathe
Boston -Tara/Marriah/Lehka - do you know anyone who might be interested
in alos trying out this sort of thing -would love to see a few cafes hosted on this theme (if it makes sense) so we could
pool questions to dhaka on june 29's dialogue day with the world's most experienced microbankers http://yunusforum.net
London- mostofa, laura, robert, peter R
- does parallel question make sense to anyone you know
LA
Melanie, philippa -ditto -anyone else - ditto? eg Nina in Florida or Alex in DC
suppose the main bangladesh and other microcredits offered a united
design service to eg usa communities in terms of banker as sort of job ebay -if we could rehearse in more
detail than below what sort of usa community profiles would come to such a desgin resource, we could ask our bangladesh friends
whether they could organise such a joint effort
what are the skills that such a banker would have a register of people able to offer -services in -Who has what skills
on call
Nursecare
Childcare
Greencare
Mealcare
Propertycare
...
What do in-network
bankers tell us other communities do more of that our community doesn’t yet have a hi-trust flexi-market
for?
How do people with a job-needing doing call in and
name a price by urgency of need and time and skill needed?
much of the above is segmented when you dig into deeper sub-communities -
for example networks of single parent families in a big city suburb probably have different compendium of exchnage needs
than say a small city with a lot of newly out of work people
-however a
main point for exploration now is: WHAT IF a confederation of community bankers actually shared their knoweldge
on what jobs a community needs and how to reliably mobilise them (perhaps around a library, 12th grader college or other
community centre resource) once we had enough places trying this the economy of local reliable job matching would get greater
and greater;
I am assuming that implicitly many of
the Bangladeshi and Kenyan bank branch managers do this sort of thing albeit in their rural village centre - now while that was geographically
easier to organsise in rural bangladesh, in today's mobile age why should be that hard if we are
going to rebuild community to see the bank branch managers as being centre of community ebay job exchanges fitted to rosters
of people with proven skills and capacity to serve
it is necessary to start open community surveys somewhere- if you think an organisation is
already doing this, introduce us!
let's explore why is this different from conventional making of
job markets -
-opportunity of the banker is helping
and the bank is owned by the community
-here the job centre isnt run by out-of community government bureacurats but ideally by members of the community
-opportunity as a lot
of job descriptions stop being separated as teachers, as librarians, as bankers of, of those who ensure that
servoice job conracts are honored ...
-now too collaboration may start to see and map that where a strong community of place or of demographic
exists this sort of bank quickly gets better and better and starts creating replications other communitrie scan sue; and equally
where it doesnt that is a place or demographic who most need extra social impact support before anything is going to develop
for and with them
-somehow
if we could get a cluster of these concept community banks up and running ot would probably then be easy to design a white
book facebook (social network tool) which each community used for banker as job ebay
does
anyone see how to start improving this or am I talking to myself.
suppose the main bangladesh and other
microcredits offered a united design service to eg usa communities in terms of banker as sort of job ebay -if
we could rehearse in more detail than below what sort of usa community profiles would come to such a desgin resource,
we could ask our bangladesh friends whether they could organise such a joint effort
what are the skills that such a banker
would have a register of people able to offer -services in -Who has what skills on call
7 years
and about 200 cafes ago we began as a loose collaboration city network interested in the following things:
how do we host 1 hour meetings where people meet hoping that some of them will continue after the meeting
in teams that social action some doable and communally worthwhile goal
as we hosted
more and more cafes, we tried to keep a joing log of what are the commonalities- which themes do result in social action teams?
how do we share collaboration permission or replication franchises across cities or other communities that cafe people see
themselves as members of?
then in parallel we started doing surveys of who were
the most trusted collaboration entrepreneurs anywhere on the planet, and many of us were surprised that we had been completely
ignorant of the number 1 worldwide network already doing sustainable community building - microcredit - so we tried to start
cross-fertilising on june 29 we have an opportunity to explore 33 years of knowhow with originators of microcredit -amongst
other achivements they have sustained about 125 million jobs among the world pooreswt women and communities where no jobs
previously existed - right now we need to know how these experiences translate to nations and places where job-developing
banks have ceased to exist - this will be one of our subdialogues on june 29
at the same time there are other subdialogues one example
- as parents and people, we have always been interested in hosting collaboration cafes in schools particularly before adolescence
- why should kids discuss future work and personal banking before they need to take on all the risks of doing it on their
own- is there no microentrepreneur faculty/curriculum within all the teachers that usa employs to develop the bridghe between
childish freedom and adolescent community responsibility? what are the main ages in life where mentors in the community could
guide you to the next choices you will need to make before you blindly find you have to make a choice without any prep
DONT LURK NOWps at the
demos meeting on the very American Madness (mathematical accounting illiteracy, aka Fraud) of Tarp & Ppip yesterday , robert kuttner agreed 2 things:he hasnt found a way to share his
knowhow of where the future is compounding with youth and if Obama's team hasn't changed their own curve with respect
to failed banking policy within 4 months then america's last chance of 2010s not becoming the greatest depression ever
is we the people in every community - particularly undergraduate youth who as always are core to branding sustainable
social and business leadership revolutions
suggestion
that 8 of us write up a simple living note on what future banking people need
Monday, 23 March, 2009 1:00 PM
From:
"christopher macrae" <chris.macrae@yahoo.co.uk>
To: lamiya mostofa alexis julia vivian peter zasheem
avert
world slump.doc (51KB)
jargon living note is like using
one email to and fro as a wiki- focused on exploring one urgently needed communal construct
This
is an action learning -and brainstorming - exercise any 8 people could play - why not we 8 try one round of
rehearsals
confirm by reply if you are game to edit this mail like a private wiki until we
have exhausted ideas
then we can show it to others for comments, encourage other grooups of
six to have a go so we see diversity of ideas around a common goal
PLEASE EDIT THIS VERY ROUGH
START OF LIVING NOTE
1 Community sustaining banking is what 99% of people's lives need from banking -its curricula one day soon
ought to be made transparent from 4th grade up - literally why not create 12 parallel www-age graded wikis - class
of 4th graders and their mentors up to class of senior year undergraduates and their mentors -wiki could include social
actions wished for or tried within age group as well as inter school exchanges between 2 hemispheres with different poverty
or other future challenges but inmterest in learning from each other
1.1 That 7 billion people are empowered
to Q&A futures of community banking is the number 1 conversation that the network generation could attend to if our generations
united space race is towards poverty museums everywhere- it is also number 1 conversation in usa if yes we can youth
networks are now to blossom not wither
2 The most practised coaches in community banking bangladesh and gandhian india –
with mobiles and investment in people income generation and community sustainability, their basic banking models are 10 times
lower cost/less risky than the wall street designed bank became -see eg http://bankabillion.org and attached avert world slump. Their method can work anywhere that community (and so
job creation) is desperately missing - celebrate-learn-do potential slum-million success of kenya http://www.jamiibora.org/ in ending slum/orphan poverty
3 Wanted: InterCity benchmarking club that is open sourcing banks with
community contexts (type 1, 2) and bangladesh/Indian knowledge includes (for contact points ask info@worldcitizen.tv):
Glasgow
Paris
LA ( Channel
Islands )
(could we check which community delegations that have ever visited bangladesh want to be in this club)
4 Type 1 community
banking context is owned by local place . Type 2 community context is owned by a demographic group whose lifetimes are
enhanced over long periods by multiplying mutual trust and transparent action maps- eg why not a big city’s 65-95
year olds have a bank designed and owned by them. Think of internal trades that such a free market could design:
eg1 Trade between
retired nurses and others (eg basic health and companionship trades without any externalising brokers)
eg2 trade between
healthy grandmothers and families needing micro-creches
...
5 Products of community banking:
Safe deposit accounts
No credit for conspicuous
consumption or debt traps
Credit designed round income generation for individual creativity and community sustaining goals
Mobile
not property-based banking assets
Internal free markets (eg see early ideas above for elders bank)
Ownership
as a mutual geared towards round productivity needs (of poorest, or youth's new job creation or parents wanting to
mix work with family rearing) and the most vital service demands determining community sustainability (this needs
a survey process that whole community can interact openly around - contextual equivalent to the first 16 decisions of microcredit
bangladesh)
Suggested Pioneer Group of 8
Lamiya is ceo yunus secretariat and yunus forum projects knowhow/permissions
coordinator; mostofa has been doing most intercity work reporting to lamiya on youth forums over last 2 years; Zasheem
is Glasgow linksperson and Julia LA State linksperson to what banking could sustain in communities of most regional need;
Alexis is NYU second year who has interned for 8 weeks in Bangladesh and aims to be a writer on womens future capitalism;
peter is a retired chartered acountant whose webs out of new york have explored african bottom-up for quarter of a century;
alexis, peter and i try and survey new yorkers (world epicentre of failed but potentially high talent bankers) of
every sort what future of yes we can banking and first 1000 social business links will re-do if USA is to be happy and free again in millennium 3's united world beyond nations.
Vivian is producer of yunus movie and in paris which is outside of dhaka, number 1 future capitalism project testing city
and via HEC host of first smba
On road to Dhaka June 29 -some other 8 people groups could try out by theme
- eg an 8 person group on green banking. If a few groups had a go at this exercise and wrote up very short summaries these
could be shared between all attending june 29 or who wish to elarn with those who do attend. Happy for all of above "rules"
of how to communicate around this idea to be re-edited- but if we can't start people debates on future of banking the
news from usa bailouts is getting very dire.
how bangladesh - and the world's - 3 safest segmented banking systems arose
Bangladesh is little more than a third of a century young - it began with the least a new nation has
ever had- flattened in a war with west pakistan , after the British Raj had exited India and what became the 2 Pakistans
then - Pakistan to the west of India and Bangladesh to the East. The Bangladeshi's were always among the greatest collaboratove
networkers and it made sense for them to become the greatest sustanability investment bankers - to do this that had to empower
almost half a nation of women entrepreneurs whom history had consigned to undproductive pursuits - it turned out that Bangladeshi women were to become the greatest entrepreneurial revolutionaries ever seen - give them access to the internet and they multiply 10 times more value than any of the rich internetworkers
on california west coast or the mobile phone yuppies that fix themselves bank and insurance bonuses for shredding trust
in western banking - of course it may be that one day that with Obama leadership and yes we can youth - we will all will get back to business that do well by doing good but for now the story below -give or take a few edits we's love at info@wordcitizen.tv (washington DC future capitalism & social business bureau 301 881 1655) shows how the right stuff now flows out of female Bangaldesh not NY's walled streets nor dismal madison aves
Bangladeshi Microcredit
– The best sustainability investment systems women & children
can get
THE TRAGIC LOCAL IGNORANCE OF GLOBAL ECONOMISTS
The standard theories of the majority
of economics journalists and academics are now known to have been anything but transparently on the side of human beings for
over a decade. http://transparency.tvEven so, the nonsense these noisy people propagate in mass
media and academic journals on Bangladeshi microcredit impacts way beyond the normal dismal consequences that richer nations
have until recently been accustomed to.
There
are a lot of international implementations that claim to be inspired by Bangladeshi microcredit but which break fundamental
rules integral to the Bangladeshi franchise systems. Such false imitations of microcredit merit fierce and open criticism.
Conversely as Bill Clinton has bravely pointed out- the 3 major Bangladeshi microcredit systems are generating the majority
of its developing economy. The local story is almost miraculous and shows what compound whole truth of purpose can do and
network from one community to the next.
Bangladesh
is the nation which started as the world’s poorest when born to independence just over a third of a century ago. Thanks
to microcredit systems Bangladesh has been sustaining growth over decades and it is irrefutably a world leader in achieving
local millennium goals. As if this wasn’t good enough reason for humanity in a social networking age to need to relate
to simple microeconomics truths of Bangladesh’s free market to end poverty, it turns out that the Bangladesh microcredit
systems provide unique clues –as well as a national history of social business entrepreneurial maps - on how to resolve
the main fallibilities that are causing the global banking system to crash in ever more viciously expensive ways.
BANGLADESH ’S MICROCREDIT 1-2-3
The 3 main Bangladesh microcredit systems serve wholly different segments. That means they
are best in kind at what they do, but it is mathematical illiteracy to make competitive comparisons between them or tabulate
international mixes. It is also the case that at least two of the three systems are as much lifelong collaboration entrepreneur
clubs that members are invited to communally join as they are “banks” –at least in the western meaning of
this word
For about 14 years, from 1976, Grameen
pioneered the only major microcredit system. Its service offer was designed for some of the poorest and most abused women
on the planet. Join the Grameen club and we will empower you to become independent income generators; you will have peer to
peer support structures both for becoming businesswomen and supporting your choice of what community safety and future sustainability
priorities are needed. Where innovative solutions are required on life-critical needs, Grameen’s entrepreneurs will
develop community-wide solutions. The whole organization will be owned equally by the poorest members.The
way to join Grameen involves taking out typically a small loan to start up your income generation for weekly repayment over
a year, but your friendly bankers will demand no collateral, no legal contracts. They trust your own ability, and the whole
community support system that is Grameen’s responsibility for designing simply and effectively. Before Grameen was granted
an unique constitution to operate a rural bank in 1983, it had already surveyed emerging members on goals that they defined
as ending poverty communally over a generation. 16 decisions to do with education of children, basic health and safetybecame the moral contract between members and Grameen’s leadership purpose.
To this day, the 16 decisions explain the Grameen culture of never being satisfied with the
managers of each and every one of its 2000+ branches unless that operation positively discriminates towards including the
poorest in its reach. And there are now over 25 services beyond the original microloans that Grameen’s entirety as a
service network integrates round social business models. All social businesses are defined to be owned by the membership.
As businesses they are designed to sustain positive cashflow. However the surplus is reinvested back in
the purpose of the business or its replication so that its distribution ultimately reaches every community where it can make
a difference to members and their childrens’ lives.
If you ask Dr Yunus about ending poverty, he will say loans for income generation are a human
right but microcredit’s hi-trust relationship networking also opens the door to generating all micro-services of life-critical
importance. 33 years after the first microcredit experiments, Grameen is a living laboratory of health and safety, education,
media and energy innovations unlike any bank a westerner will have met. Consider just 4 of Grameen’s social business
threads – two which emerged as locally critical early on, two that are the cause of entrepreneurial revolutions http://erworld.tvof worldwide import as their sustainability exponentials have compounded
since 1996
1 Early on Grameen became the largest
seed distributor in Bangladesh . Why because Dr Yunus’ staff noted that village children had night blindness. They were
told this was because of vitamin deficiency which Grameen’s members could cure if they planted carrots. So Grameen sold
the tiniest and so lowest unit cost packs of seeds ever marketed!
2
Grameen’s rule is that credit is for either income generation or a life-critical purchase not superficial consumption.
Within years of its constitution, Grameen won an Aga Khan award for architecture. The story of Grameen’s entry into
sub sub prime is this. The government was issuing house-building aid to so-called poor people. However its definition of houses
were far too expensive for rural villagers. What these families needed was the minimum design of monsoon-proof roof over their
head and a pit latrine. Grameen developed the lowest-cost structural design and a credit policy for paying back the cost of
the house in under 5 years. In line with the 16 decisions, it also insisted that to qualify for a loan the property right
had to be turned over to the woman. Prior to this a man only had to tell his wife she was divorced and she had to leave forthwith.
Now if the man in the household did that, he had to leave! Grameen members have successfully completed quarter of a million
sub sub prime mortgages without one foreclosure.
3 1996
saw the start up of 2 most visionary community entrepreneur investments ever made by and for poor people
– the now famous mobile telephone lady and the as yet little known fact that Grameen members now install more solar
units than the whole of the USA. Prior to 1996 Grameen had evolved round nearly 100,000 village centres (meeting places owned
by the women) where up to 60 members met. Their knowhow was only connected as far as cross-fertilization of grameen’s
service employees could manage. Once every village had a shared mobile phone – an intervention which must have beenas revolutionary as a telegram office in the wild west of the 19th century – vital information started
to be networked all across 100,000 hubs. Moreover Grameen and partners picked up the mobile franchise at cents in the dollar
as global consultants were an order of magnitude out in predicting the market size of mobile phones in what they analysed
as the world’s poorest nation. Today, Grameen Phone is the largest corporate tax payer in the nation and the Grameen
share is owned by its 7 million women entrepreneurs. In the case of Grameen renewable energy http://www.gshakti.org , the plan is to create 100000 green jobs in the villages by 2012, as well as
to demonstrate how any sunshine state can develop a thriving carbon-negative economy. This is most important to Bangladesh
as the first 100+ million nation likely to be washed away if our global policies continue to melt the world’s ice and
raise sea levels
2 BRAC spent
most of Bangladesh ’s first 2 decades developing healthcare and primary education services. Alongside this it started
developing at least 3 industry sectors to be owned bottom-up by the poorest women : poultry, other livestock, silk farming
and fashions. When BRAC started microcredit around 1990, we can well imagine its main focus was to empower individuals to
start up businesses which contributed to these industry sectors. Unlike Grameen, BRAC’s constitution was not restricted
to village banking. Its own use of information technology has always been at the infrastructure level first as opposed to
Grameen’s delivery to end users in the community. Thus BRAC became a leader in automating banking transactions. It now
runs a for-profit city banking chain alongside its microcredit to end rural poverty
3 ASA has also existed as a social services network since the 1970s but around 1990 it entered
and then focused entirely on microbanking. Unlike Grameen or BRAC, it does not itself design entrepreneurial franchises beyond
pure financial services. It is primarily banking for those among the individual poor who after 20 years of communally operated
microcredit now want to be served individually without the need of peer support groups or village-wide goals. Potentially,
ASA is the nearest system design the West may compare to what Main Street might want from local banks on the side of investing
in the productivity of the customer as well as the hi-trust community-building which families need invested in.
This brief review does not begin to indicate the worldwide potential
for sustainabilityinvestment understanding which Bangladesh microcredit models are now interacting with
our digital age. For example, India and Bangladesh are teaming up to develop the next generation of mobile microbanking http://bankabillion.org so that the costs of basic banking become 10 times less to operate. Kenya ’s
leading microcredit http://jamiibora.org was born after the age of mobile connectivity. In under a decade its 300000 members
(doubling almost annually) have become the world’s leading example of microcredit that empowers job creation among slum
youth as well as rural women. The Oscar-winning moving slumdog millionaire doesn’t begin to tell how exciting Jamii
Bora's story and contribution to ending poverty can be.
Other
microcredit channels that have a long reputation of being both transparent measurers and bottom-up agencies are now hi-trust
networking’s perfect partners for co-creating free markets with mobiles. http://microenergycredits.com forms partnerships between local microcredits and small scale solar suppliers; by aggregating
how many households can verifiably be identified as zero-carbon users, carbon credit markets can return the value to the poorest
who make the changeover to renewable energy. MEC is determined to make a clean energy market between 250 million households
worldwide in time to celebrate other 2015 millennium goals. CEO leaders networks clustered around John Mackey are celebrating
sustainable capitalism’s development of fair trade partnerships with the support of local microcredits http://wholeplanetfoundation.org(See also the new book
- Be the Solution: How Entrepreneurs and Conscious Capitalists Can Solve All the Worlds
Problems (Hardcover) by Michael Strong , John Mackey )
INDUSTRY SECTOR RESPONSIBILITY
Dr Yunus’s own new book “Creating a world without
poverty –Social Business, Future of Capitalism” reviews the third of a century through which Bangladesh became
the most collaborative innovator and economic social business networker. Since winning the Nobel Peace Prize, Dr Yunus has
upped the challenge. How about playing Future Capitalism games and all types of media celebrating them more tham March Madness
or four-yearly Olympics? The first FC game involves heroic innovation partnerships matching the world’s most resourced
organizations and deepest grassroots networks. The search is on for service solutions to the most life-critical needs which
an industry sector is uniquely capable of. Why would a global corporation spend a billion dollars on image-making campaigns
when it faces this outstanding media opportunity reality-making? Worldwide youth and free markets of ending poverty can now
celebrate a global company’s reputation gain for helping innovate the most responsible innovation its sector can create,
while the poorest own the social business so that sustainable surpluses are invested back in replicating a life-saving solution.
About 20 such goodwill multiplying partnerships have begun during the first year of Dr Yunus launching the challenge of Future
Capitalism partnering http://www.yunuspartners.com
Yes
this generation can make and celebrate our networking space race as that of ending poverty. We will need to replace historically
backward looking economics analysts by true future capitalism reporters. These will typically be youthful visitors of local contexts of grassroots microcredit. Those
whose peers share the love of mapping how sustainable microeconomics win-win-wins and how social business networks multiply
exponentials up over longer periods of time than the quarterised MBA mindsets know. Help us log up a 1000 replicable social
business franchises at http://socialbusiness.tv ; join in demanding an annual yearbook on Future Capitalism edited out of Dhaka as
world’s number 1 sustainability investment city. RSVP info@worldcitizen.tv with a more exciting way
of seeing what future generation investment in people instead of yesterday’s machines can truly credit.
The world of 2009 has been described by President Obama as one in
which global top-down has been proven not to work. Microeconomists and entrepreneurial revolutionaries have 33
years of experiments in choosing another way that are waiting to be open sourced worldwide. This is in all probability the
year we breach irreversibility’s tipping point - if we fail to unite in valuing how to prevent a decade-long slump and
potential loss of human sustainability. To microeconomists evidence of the need for a new capitalism has been compounding
since 1976- not just in the practice of Dr Yunus -and 200000 plus sustainability investment microbankers of Bangladesh - but
in the surveys of Entrepreneurial Revolution published from the Christmas 1976 issue of The Economist. When a networking generation
wants to integrate more value than zero-sum globalization, the entrepreneurial “must” is to go micro and then
open source solutions that microentrpreneurially work- replicating them anywhere that societies want to
test them transparently.
Future Capitalism - Yes We Can Unite in
Do This Now
http://muhammadyunus.org/content/view/194/128/lang,en/. What John Lennon could only imagine, President
Obama is uniquely qualified to help action as a son of microcredit, and with his fatherland of Kenya Jamii Bora
providing a template which in Africa ’s context can value multiply even more job creation than Grameen. Do we not owe
Dr Yunus’ and the Bangladesh nation’s open invitation to end poverty the human values of whole hearted networking
transparency and true grassroots empowerment? Wouldn’t it be far less wasteful than bailing out (so far 13 trillion
dollars of ) big banking and insurance systems whose global mis-economy has already overshot the claim –let
alone humanity’s credit - of being too big to fail?
With
special thanks to a 3rd grade New Yorker for revealing how simple microcredit Q&A of 1000 people communities
is in January 2008.